9 min read
This topic follows a trade from the order to settlement, then what holders see afterward: returns, cost basis, dividends, splits and other company actions.
Bids, asks and order types
The bid is a price at which someone will buy. The ask, or offer, is a price at which someone will sell. Across markets, the best bid is the highest bid and the best offer is the lowest offer.
- Market order: trades now, usually near the ask (buying) or bid (selling), with the most certainty of execution but no price guarantee.
- Limit order: a buy fills only at the limit or lower, a sell only at the limit or higher. It may never fill, and it never becomes a market order.
- Stop order: becomes a market order once the stop price is reached, so the fill can be far from the stop.
- A sell stop sits below the market and limits loss on stock you own. A buy stop sits above it and limits loss on a short position.
- Stop-limit order: reaching the stop activates a limit order, which may stay unfilled.
- Day order: expires at the day's close, and is the default with no stated time frame.
- Good 'til canceled (GTC): stays open until executed or canceled.
Example
(a) Market A quotes PRT at 30.10 bid, 30.16 ask. Market B quotes 30.12 bid, 30.18 ask. Find the best bid and best offer.
(b) NVQ last traded at $60. One customer has a sell stop at $55. Another has a sell stop-limit with a $55 stop and $55 limit. NVQ opens at $49 and stays there. What happens to each?
Solution
(a) Highest bid: 30.12. Lowest offer: 30.16.
(b) The stop becomes a market order, filling near $49. The stop-limit becomes a sell limit at $55 and stays unfilled.
Capacity, solicitation and discretion
Capacity is a firm's role in a trade. An agent trades with another party for the customer and earns a commission. A principal trades from its own account. A confirmation, the written trade notice, is due at or before completion (SEC Rule 10b-10; MSRB Rule G-15 for municipals).
- Rule 10b-10 confirmations state capacity.
- Agency trade: also the firm's pay from the customer and the other party's name, or that it is available on written request.
- Principal trade: also whether the firm is a market maker in the security. Some must show the markup.
- Unsolicited order: the customer starts the contact and names the security. Solicited order: it comes from contact the firm started.
- Regulation Best Interest applies when a recommendation is made to a retail customer, not to every trade.
- Discretion (FINRA Rule 3260): choosing the security or amount needs the customer's prior written authorization and the firm's written acceptance.
- Time-and-price exception: a customer who names the amount and security can leave timing and price to the representative, generally until the end of that business day.
- SEC Rule 17a-3: the order memorandum marks discretionary orders.
Example
With no written authorization on file, may a representative act on these?
(a) "Sell my 200 RST today when the price looks good."
(b) "Buy 200 shares of whichever energy stock you like."
Solution
(a) Yes. The customer named the security and amount, leaving only time and price.
(b) No. The representative would choose the security.
Long, short, bullish and bearish
Long means you own the position. Short means you sold what you do not own, or delivered borrowed shares. Bullish investors expect a rise, and bearish investors expect a fall.
- Bullish: long stock or a long call (the right to buy at a set price).
- Bearish: a short sale or a long put (the right to sell at a set price).
- Locate rule (Regulation SHO Rule 203): before accepting a short sale, a firm must borrow the stock, arrange to, or reasonably believe it can be borrowed, and document this.
- Covered call: the writer owns the stock. Naked call: the writer does not, and the possible loss is theoretically unlimited.
Example
An investor sells short 200 shares at $60. What is the result if she buys them back at (a) $52 or (b) $68? Ignore costs.
Solution
(a) ($60 − $52) × 200 = $1,600 gain.
(b) ($60 − $68) × 200 = −$1,600, a loss.
Measuring return
Return comes from income (interest and dividends) and price change. A gain is unrealized while you still hold the investment and realized when you sell.
- Stock yield: annual dividends ÷ market price.
- Current yield: annual coupon ÷ bond price.
- Yield to maturity (YTM): the annual return if a bond is held to maturity, given the price paid. It tops the coupon on a discount bond and trails it on a premium bond.
- Yield to call (YTC): the return if the bond is redeemed at the call price on its call date.
- Total return: change in value plus income. Percent return = (change in value + income) ÷ amount invested.
- Basis point: 0.01 of a percentage point.
- Benchmarks: the Dow Jones Industrial Average tracks 30 blue-chip stocks, the S&P 500 tracks 500 leading companies, and the Wilshire 5000 aims to measure the whole U.S. stock market.
Example
(a) A $45 stock pays $0.45 a quarter. Find its yield.
(b) $5,000 of stock grows to $5,500 and pays $150 in dividends. Find percent return.
(c) A $1,000 bond pays $50 a year and trades at $950. Find current yield.
(d) A yield moves from 5.15% to 5.40%. How many basis points?
Solution
(a) $0.45 × 4 = $1.80. $1.80 ÷ $45 = 4%.
(b) ($500 + $150) ÷ $5,000 = 13%.
(c) $50 ÷ $950 = 5.26%.
(d) 0.25 ÷ 0.01 = 25 basis points.
Cost basis and taxes
Cost basis is the purchase price plus commissions and fees. Gain or loss is the sale amount minus adjusted basis.
- Holding period: count from the day after purchase through the day of sale. More than one year is long-term. One year or less is short-term, taxed at ordinary rates.
- Lots: if you do not identify the shares sold, the earliest shares count as sold.
- Wash sale: buying substantially identical stock within 30 days before or after a loss sale bars the deduction. The loss is added to the new shares' basis.
- Return of capital: a nondividend distribution is untaxed at first and lowers basis. Once basis reaches zero, more is a capital gain.
- Form 1099-B: for most stock bought for cash in an account after 2010 (a covered security), the broker reports adjusted basis and proceeds.
Example
(a) A customer buys 300 shares at $18 and pays a $15 commission. Find her basis.
(b) He buys stock on June 10, 2025. When does a sale first count as long-term?
(c) She buys 100 shares at $22 in March and 100 at $38 in May, then sells 100 at $45 without naming a lot. Find the gain.
(d) He buys 200 shares at $30 and sells at $24. Twelve days later he buys 200 at $26. Find the new basis.
Solution
(a) (300 × $18) + $15 = $5,415.
(b) Counting starts June 11, 2025, so June 10, 2026 is exactly one year. The first long-term date is June 11, 2026.
(c) The March lot counts as sold: ($45 − $22) × 100 = $2,300.
(d) Disallowed loss: ($30 − $24) × 200 = $1,200. New basis: (200 × $26) + $1,200 = $6,400.
Settlement and how securities are held
Trade date (T) is when an order executes. Settlement date is when money and securities must be delivered. Since May 2024 the standard has been T+1, the next business day. SEC Rule 15c6-1 sets that limit for stocks and corporate bonds unless the parties expressly agree otherwise.
- T+1 also applies to bonds, options, ETFs, certain mutual funds, U.S. government securities and exchange-traded limited partnerships.
- Municipal trades settle T+1 regular way under MSRB Rule G-15.
- Cash trade: delivery on the trade date itself (T).
- Firm-commitment offering priced after 4:30 p.m. ET: a cash sale may settle as late as T+2.
- Certificate: a registered owner can hold paper. Book entry: an electronic record, with no paper.
- Street name: shares are registered to a nominee and tracked on the brokerage firm's books, while the customer is the beneficial owner.
- Direct registration: book-entry shares in the owner's own name, recorded by the company's transfer agent rather than a broker.
- Treasury: marketable securities are book-entry only.
Example
With no holidays, when do these settle?
(a) A listed stock bought regular way on Thursday.
(b) A municipal bond bought regular way on Friday.
(c) A stock traded for cash on Wednesday.
Solution
(a) Friday, one business day later.
(b) Monday, because weekends are not business days.
(c) Wednesday, the same day.
Dividends and order adjustments
A cash dividend moves through four dates: the board declares it, the record date fixes who is on the company's books, the ex-dividend date is the first day a buyer no longer gets it, and the payable date is when it arrives.
- FINRA Rule 11140, under 25% of the security's value: the ex-date is the record date if that is a business day, and otherwise usually the prior business day.
- Rule 11140, 25% or more (including a 3-for-2 split): the ex-date is the first business day after the payable date.
- SEC Rule 10b-17: an issuer must generally give notice at least 10 days before the record date for dividends, splits, reverse splits and rights.
- FINRA Rule 5330, for orders not governed by exchange rules, adjusts open buy orders and open sell stops. Open sell limits and buy stops are left alone.
- Cash dividend: lower the order price by the dividend, unless marked Do Not Reduce.
- Forward split: lower the price and raise the size. Do Not Increase blocks the size change.
- Reverse split: cancel pending buy and sell orders.
Example
(a) A record date is Wednesday, a business day. Will a buyer on Tuesday, or on Wednesday, get the dividend?
(b) An OTC stock pays $0.40. What happens to a sell stop at $50?
(c) What happens to an OTC buy limit for 200 shares at $60 after a 3-for-2 split?
Solution
(a) Ex-date is Wednesday. Tuesday's buyer settles Wednesday and gets it. Wednesday's buyer settles Thursday and does not.
(b) $50.00 − $0.40 = $49.60.
(c) Price: $60 × 2/3 = $40. Size: 200 × 3/2 = 300 shares.
Corporate actions and proxies
A corporate action is a company event that changes what holders own or asks them to decide. A split or reverse split changes the share count and price, not the position's value. Total basis stays the same and spreads over the new share count.
- Stock dividend: generally not taxable when received. Divide the old basis across old and new shares.
- Buyback: a company buys its own shares. The voluntary Rule 10b-18 safe harbor generally caps daily purchases at 25% of average daily trading volume.
- Tender offer: an offer to buy securities from holders, open at least 20 business days, and at least 10 after a change in price or amount sought. An **issuer tender offer** comes from the company itself.
- Exchange offer: a tender offer that pays in securities.
- Rights offering: existing holders may buy more shares for cash, in proportion to what they hold.
- Merger: stock received for stock in a reorganization generally produces no gain or loss now. The old basis carries over.
- Proxy: a vote cast for a holder. A firm forwards proxy materials to beneficial owners within five business days, given assurance of reimbursement.
- FINRA Rule 2251: a firm may not vote street-name stock it does not own unless an exception applies. Being holder of record is not enough.
Example
(a) A customer owns 400 shares at $75, with a $20,000 basis. After a 4-for-1 split, find shares, price, value and basis per share.
(b) A $2 stock does a 1-for-8 reverse split. What happens to 1,600 shares?
(c) A customer with 200 shares and a $6,300 basis gets a nontaxable 5% stock dividend. Find basis per share.
Solution
(a) 400 × 4 = 1,600 shares. $75 ÷ 4 = $18.75. Value: 1,600 × $18.75 = $30,000, unchanged. Basis: $20,000 ÷ 1,600 = $12.50.
(b) 1,600 ÷ 8 = 200 shares. $2 × 8 = $16.
(c) 200 × 1.05 = 210 shares. $6,300 ÷ 210 = $30.
Key terms
- Bid
- Price at which someone will buy; the highest one across markets is the best.
- Ask
- Price at which someone will sell, also called the offer; the lowest is the best.
- Market order
- Instruction to trade right away at the going price, with no price guarantee.
- Limit order
- Instruction to buy at or below, or sell at or above, a set price.
- Stop order
- Instruction that turns into a market trade once a set trigger price is reached.
- Good 'til canceled (GTC)
- Time instruction keeping an order open until executed or withdrawn.
- Agent
- Firm role: trades with another party for the customer and earns a commission.
- Principal
- Firm role: trades from its own account with the customer.
- Short sale
- Selling a security you do not own, or delivering borrowed shares to complete the trade.
- Yield to maturity
- Annual return if a bond is bought at market and held until repayment of par.
- Basis point
- One-hundredth of 1 percent of yield.
- Total return
- Change in value plus income; divide by the amount invested for the percent.
- Cost basis
- Purchase price plus commissions and fees, used to figure gain or loss.
- Wash sale
- Selling at a loss and buying substantially identical stock within 30 days either side; the loss is disallowed.
- T+1
- Settlement one business day after the trade date; the standard since May 2024.
- Street name
- Registration to a nominee, with the customer as beneficial owner on the firm's books.
- Record date
- Day that fixes which holders on the company's books get a dividend or proxy materials.
- Ex-dividend date
- First day a buyer no longer gets a declared payment; usually the record date under FINRA Rule 11140.
- Tender offer
- Proposal to buy securities from holders, open at least 20 business days.
- Proxy
- A shareholder's vote cast through someone else, usually by a form sent to holders.
Common mistakes
- A limit order never converts to a market order. Only a stop becomes a market order, and a stop-limit becomes a limit order.
- A stop order does not guarantee the stop price. If a stock gaps past the stop, the order fills at the going market price.
- Exactly one year is still short-term. The holding period must be more than one year, and counting starts the day after purchase.
- A wash sale loss is not gone for good. It is added to the basis of the new shares.
- With T+1, the ex-date is usually the record date itself, not one business day before it. It moves earlier only if the record date is not a business day.
- Reverse splits cancel open orders under Rule 5330. Cash dividends and forward splits adjust them.
Checked against: FINRA for Investors: Order Types; FINRA for Investors: Options; FINRA for Investors: Evaluating Performance; FINRA for Investors: Bonds; FINRA Investor Insights: Capital Gains Explained; FINRA Investor Insights: Understanding Settlement Cycles; FINRA Rule 2251 (Processing and Forwarding of Proxy and Other Issuer-Related Materials); FINRA Rule 3260 (Discretionary Accounts); FINRA Rule 5330 (Adjustment of Orders); FINRA Rule 11140 (Transactions in Securities "Ex-Dividend," "Ex-Rights" or "Ex-Warrants"); FINRA Rule 11320 (Dates of Delivery); MSRB Rule G-15 (Confirmation, Clearance, Settlement and Other Uniform Practice Requirements); SEC Rule 15c6-1 (Settlement Cycle), 17 CFR 240.15c6-1; SEC Rule 10b-10 (Confirmation of Transactions), 17 CFR 240.10b-10; SEC Rule 10b-17 (Untimely Announcements of Record Dates), 17 CFR 240.10b-17; SEC Rule 10b-18 (Purchases of Certain Equity Securities by the Issuer and Others), 17 CFR 240.10b-18; SEC Rule 14b-1 (Prompt Forwarding of Certain Communications), 17 CFR 240.14b-1; SEC Rule 14e-1 (Unlawful Tender Offer Practices), 17 CFR 240.14e-1; SEC Rule 13e-4 (Tender Offers by Issuers), 17 CFR 240.13e-4; SEC Rule 17a-3 (Records to Be Made by Brokers and Dealers), 17 CFR 240.17a-3; SEC Regulation Best Interest, 17 CFR 240.15l-1; SEC Regulation NMS Rule 600 (Definitions), 17 CFR 242.600; SEC Regulation SHO Rule 200 (Definition of Short Sale and Marking Requirements), 17 CFR 242.200; SEC Regulation SHO Rule 203 (Borrowing and Delivery Requirements), 17 CFR 242.203; SEC Rule 800 (Definitions), 17 CFR 230.800; SEC Concept Release: Transfer Agent Regulations (Release 34-76743); SEC: Market Indices; Uniform Offering Circular for Treasury Securities, 31 CFR 356.4; 26 CFR 1.1012-1 (Basis of Property), paragraph (c); 26 U.S.C. 1091 (Loss from Wash Sales of Stock or Securities); IRS Topic No. 409, Capital Gains and Losses; IRS Topic No. 404, Dividends and Other Corporate Distributions; IRS Topic No. 703, Basis of Assets; IRS Publication 550, Investment Income and Expenses; IRS Instructions for Form 1099-B; IRS FAQ: Stocks (Options, Splits, Traders); SEC Investor Bulletin: What Are Corporate Bonds?; MSRB Glossary of Municipal Securities Terms; SEC Investor.gov: Day Order; SEC Investor.gov: New "T+1" Settlement Cycle, Investor Bulletin