Skip to content
Ticker Prep
Open app

Chapter 11 of 13 · Trading and accounts

SIE prohibited activities

Chapter quiz ↓All trading and accounts questions

All chapters

7 min read

Securities law bans conduct that fakes a market, exploits secret information or abuses a customer's trust. This lesson explains each practice, how to tell them apart, and the penalties.

Market manipulation

Market manipulation creates a false picture of a security's price or activity to lure investors. Exchange Act Section 9 bans it, and Rule 2020 of FINRA, the industry's self-regulator, bars manipulative or deceptive devices.

  • **Wash sale:** a trade with no change in **beneficial ownership**, meaning the true owner stays the same.
  • **Matched orders:** knowingly placing offsetting orders of about the same size, time and price to fake activity. The owners can differ.
  • **Market rumors:** Section 9(a)(4) bars a seller from stating a material fact, to induce buying, that he has reason to believe is false. FINRA Rule 6140(e) sets a similar bar for members.
  • **Pump and dump:** spreading hype to push up a stock, often a tiny one, then selling at the inflated price.
  • **Marking the close or open:** trading at or near the end or start of a session to push that price. FINRA's Sanction Guidelines list both.
  • **Excessive trading:** recommended trades that are too much when taken together. Turnover rate and cost-equity ratio are measures; no single test decides it.
  • **Paid promotion (Rule 5230):** a firm may not pay to influence a publication unless the piece is clearly paid advertising, discloses the payment, or is a research report.

Example

Name each: (a) A trader sells between two accounts he alone owns. (b) Two friends agree to enter opposite 5,000-share orders at one price. (c) A trader buys above the offer at day's end to lift the closing price.

Solution

(a) Ownership never changes, so a wash sale.

(b) Ownership changes, so matched orders.

(c) Marking the close.

Trading ahead and other market abuses

  • **Front running (Rule 5270):** trading a security or a related instrument, such as options, while knowing of an imminent **block** (generally 10,000 shares or more), until the news is public or stale.
  • **Trading ahead of a customer (Rule 5320):** a firm holding a customer order may not trade the same side at a price that would fill it without immediately filling the customer at that price or better.
  • **Trading ahead of research (Rule 5280):** changing the firm's own holdings on advance knowledge of a research report.
  • **Backing away (Rule 5220):** refusing to trade at your own **firm quote**, a price you must honor.
  • **Coordination (Rule 5240):** coordinating prices, or pressuring a rival to change a quote, as by refusing to trade.
  • **Freeriding:** buying in a pay-in-full cash account and selling before paying. Regulation T then bars delayed payment for 90 calendar days.

Example

A firm holds a customer's order to buy 300 shares at $15, then buys 300 at $15 for itself. What must it do?

Solution

Fill the customer's 300 shares immediately at $15 or better. Otherwise it has traded ahead.

Insider trading

Insider trading is trading on material nonpublic information in breach of a duty of trust. Information is material when a reasonable investor would likely consider it important to a buy or sell decision. There is no percentage test.

  • **Awareness (Rule 10b5-1):** being aware of the information when trading is enough, whatever the motive.
  • **Who is involved:** SEC cases have reached officers, directors and employees; their **tippees** (friends, family and associates who trade on a tip); lawyers, bankers and printers working for the company; and government staff.
  • **Plan defense:** a contract or written plan adopted before learning the information can protect later trades.
  • **Misappropriation (Rule 10b5-2):** outsiders owe a duty if they agreed to keep a secret, have a history of sharing confidences, or got it from a spouse, parent, child or sibling.
  • **Tippers:** passing on the information is a violation even without trading.

Example

Who owes a duty? (a) A brother tips his sister about a merger. (b) A stranger overhears news on a train. (c) Two friends with a long habit of keeping each other's work secrets.

Solution

(a) Yes, siblings are listed, though she may rebut it.

(b) No listed relationship and no agreement.

(c) Yes, a pattern of confidences creates a duty.

Insider trading penalties

  • **Civil penalty (Section 21A):** up to three times the profit or avoided loss. Loss avoided uses the trading price a reasonable period after the news is public.
  • **Firms:** a controlling person pays only if it knew of or recklessly ignored a likely violation, or recklessly failed to keep required policies.
  • **Private suits (Section 20A):** investors trading at the same time can recover up to the profit or loss avoided, less any **disgorgement** (gains given up under a court order). A tipper is jointly and severally liable with the person tipped, so either can be made to pay the full amount.
  • **Criminal (Section 32(a)):** up to $5 million and 20 years for a person, and up to $25 million for an entity.
  • **FINRA:** by law it can fine, censure, suspend or expel a member firm, and suspend or bar a person from the industry. A 2018 marking-the-close decision barred a trader.

Example

An officer sells 4,000 shares at $50 knowing undisclosed bad news. After the news is public, the stock trades at $35. What is the maximum civil penalty, and the most he could owe investors trading at the same time?

Solution

Loss avoided = ($50 − $35) × 4,000 = $60,000.

Maximum civil penalty = 3 × $60,000 = $180,000.

Section 20A cap = $60,000, less anything disgorged.

Fraud, customer money and IPOs

  • **Rule 10b-5:** bans schemes to defraud, false statements or misleading omissions of material fact, and deceptive conduct.
  • **Registration claims (Rule 15c1-3):** a firm may not suggest SEC registration means the SEC approved it or its products.
  • **Improper use (Rule 2150):** taking customer money is a violation, even if meant to be repaid.
  • **Guarantees:** no one may guarantee a customer against loss.
  • **Sharing in accounts:** needs prior written authorization from the firm and customer, and only in proportion to the money contributed. Accounts of parents, parents-in-law, spouses, children and supported relatives are exempt from the proportion limit.
  • **Borrowing (Rule 3240):** generally banned unless firm procedures allow it and the lender fits a listed category. Personal-relationship loans need notice and written pre-approval.
  • **IPOs (Rule 5130):** **restricted persons**, including broker-dealer staff and portfolio managers, may not buy a **new issue** (an equity IPO). Family members are restricted only with material support, a job at the selling firm or allocation control.
  • **10% exemption:** an account may buy if restricted persons hold 10% or less.

Example

An RR put 25% of the money into a $40,000 joint account with an unrelated customer, with both written authorizations in place. The account gains $8,000. What is his largest share?

Solution

He may share only in proportion to his contribution: 25% × $8,000 = $2,000.

Seniors, unregistered persons and records

  • **Rule 2165:** a firm may place a temporary hold on a disbursement or trade for a **specified adult** (65 or older, or 18 or older and impaired) if it reasonably believes exploitation is occurring.
  • **Notice:** account parties and the trusted contact are told within two business days, unless suspected.
  • **Paying unregistered persons (Rule 2040):** no trade-based pay to someone who would have to register as a broker-dealer, and the firm must be able to support its view that registration is not needed. Retiring **registered representatives (RRs)**, a firm's licensed salespeople, may keep commissions under a bona fide contract barring soliciting and servicing.
  • **Taking orders (Rule 1230):** accepting orders is not clerical, so whoever accepts them must be registered. When a registered person is occasionally unavailable, an unregistered assistant may write down details, but the registered person confirms them with the customer before entry.
  • **Soliciting (Rule 1220):** FINRA defines a representative as anyone associated with a member who is engaged in its securities business, and solicitation is on that list. So an unregistered assistant may not solicit customers.
  • **False records:** changing an order time falsifies a required record under SEC Rule 17a-3.
  • **Signatures of convenience:** signing a customer's name, even on an authorized trade, is unauthorized use of a signature under Rule 2010. An authorized trade or later customer approval can lower the sanction, not erase it.
  • **Keeping records (Rule 4511):** firms must make and preserve required books and records, in a format meeting SEC Rule 17a-4. With no set period, FINRA's default is six years. Discarding a record early is a violation too.
  • **Regulatory requests (Rule 8210):** firms and associated persons must provide information and testimony, including outside-activity records in their possession, custody or control. Failing to provide them, or withholding them, breaks the rule.

Example

How long can a Rule 2165 hold last with every extension?

Solution

15 initial + 10 after review + 30 after reporting to a state regulator, agency or court = 55 business days.

Key terms

Wash sale
A trade that leaves true ownership unchanged, used to fake market activity.
Matched orders
Offsetting orders of similar size, time and price placed knowingly to fake activity; owners may differ.
Pump and dump
Hyping a stock with misleading claims, then selling your shares at the inflated price.
Marking the close
Trading near the end of the session to set an artificial closing price.
Front running
Trading ahead of an imminent block transaction while its details are material and nonpublic.
Backing away
Failing to honor one's own firm quotation.
Freeriding
Selling in a cash account before paying; brings a 90-calendar-day freeze on delayed payment.
Material
Substantially likely to matter to a reasonable investor deciding whether to buy or sell.
Misappropriation
Trading on, or passing along, secret information taken by betraying a duty of trust or confidence.
Tipper
A person who unlawfully passes on inside information; liable even without trading.
Section 21A penalty
Civil fine of up to three times the profit or avoided loss.
Section 20A cap
Investors trading at the same time recover at most the profit or loss avoided, less disgorgement.
Restricted person
Someone barred from buying equity IPOs, such as broker-dealer staff and portfolio managers.
De minimis exemption
An IPO may go to an account if barred investors hold no more than 10% of it.
Specified adult
A customer 65 or older, or 18 or older with an impairment preventing self-protection.
Beneficial ownership
The true economic interest in a security, whatever name appears on the account.
Tippee
A person who receives inside information from someone else and trades on it.
Expulsion
FINRA's removal of a member firm from membership, one of the sanctions federal law lets it impose.
Signature of convenience
Signing for a customer to save time; unauthorized use of a signature even when the trade itself was authorized.

Common mistakes

  • A wash sale keeps one owner. Matched orders can have different owners. Check whether ownership changes.
  • Front running means a block is coming. Trading ahead of a customer means the firm already holds a customer order. Research front running involves a report.
  • Insider trading needs only awareness at the time of the trade, with no profit minimum and no sole-motive test.
  • Three times the gain is the Section 21A ceiling. The Section 20A cap is one times, reduced by disgorgement.
  • Sharing profits follows the contribution unless the relative is on Rule 2150's list. A sibling you do not support is not listed, even though Rule 3240 counts siblings as family.
  • Rule 5130 does not cover follow-on offerings by public companies, and an adult child with no support tie and no job at the selling firm is not automatically restricted.

Checked against: 15 U.S.C. 78i (Exchange Act Section 9, Manipulation of security prices); 15 U.S.C. 78t-1 (Exchange Act Section 20A, Liability to contemporaneous traders for insider trading); 15 U.S.C. 78u-1 (Exchange Act Section 21A, Civil penalties for insider trading); 15 U.S.C. 78ff (Exchange Act Section 32, Penalties); SEC Rule 10b-5 (Employment of manipulative and deceptive devices); SEC Rule 10b5-1 (Trading on the basis of material nonpublic information); SEC Rule 10b5-2 (Duties of trust or confidence in misappropriation cases); SEC Rule 12b-2 (Definitions, including material); SEC Rule 15c1-3 (Misrepresentation by brokers and dealers as to registration); SEC Rule 17a-3 (Records to Be Made by Certain Exchange Members, Brokers and Dealers); SEC Rule 15l-1 (Regulation Best Interest); 12 CFR 220.8 (Regulation T, cash account); SEC: Microcap Stock, A Guide for Investors; FINRA Office of Hearing Officers, Department of Market Regulation v. Meagher, No. 2011030509802 (2018); FINRA Rule 2111 (Suitability); FINRA Rule 5230 (Payments Involving Publications that Influence the Market Price of a Security); FINRA Rule 5270 (Front Running of Block Transactions); FINRA Rule 5320 (Prohibition Against Trading Ahead of Customer Orders); FINRA Rule 5280 (Trading Ahead of Research Reports); FINRA Rule 5220 (Offers at Stated Prices); FINRA Rule 5240 (Anti-Intimidation/Coordination); FINRA Rule 2150 (Improper Use of Customers' Securities or Funds; Prohibition Against Guarantees and Sharing in Accounts); FINRA Rule 5130 (Restrictions on the Purchase and Sale of Initial Equity Public Offerings); FINRA Rule 2165 (Financial Exploitation of Specified Adults); FINRA Rule 2020 (Use of Manipulative, Deceptive or Other Fraudulent Devices); FINRA Rule 6140 (Other Trading Practices); FINRA Rule 3240 (Borrowing From or Lending to Customers); FINRA Rule 2040 (Payments to Unregistered Persons); FINRA Rule 1230 (Associated Persons Exempt from Registration), Supplementary Material .01; FINRA Rule 8210 (Provision of Information and Testimony and Inspection and Copying of Books); SEC Investor.gov: Insider Trading; SEC Investor.gov: Market Manipulation; 15 U.S.C. 78o-3 (Exchange Act Section 15A, Registered securities associations), paragraph (b)(7); SEC Rule 17a-4 (Records to Be Preserved by Certain Exchange Members, Brokers and Dealers); FINRA Rule 4511 (General Requirements); SEC: Guide to Broker-Dealer Registration; FINRA Sanction Guidelines (March 2024); FINRA Rule 8310 (Sanctions for Violation of the Rules); FINRA Rule 1220 (Registration Categories)

Chapter quiz

8 questions from this chapter, with an explanation after each answer.

1/8

Prohibited activities

A registered representative learns that an institutional customer is about to place an order to buy 80,000 shares of XYZ. Before the order is entered and before the information is public, the representative buys XYZ for a personal account. What has the representative done?

← Customer accounts and compliance

Written and checked by AI against the sources above on October 31, 2026. No FINRA-registered or licensed professional has reviewed it. How we check.