7 min read
Securities law bans conduct that fakes a market, exploits secret information or abuses a customer's trust. This lesson explains each practice, how to tell them apart, and the penalties.
Market manipulation
Market manipulation creates a false picture of a security's price or activity to lure investors. Exchange Act Section 9 bans it, and Rule 2020 of FINRA, the industry's self-regulator, bars manipulative or deceptive devices.
- **Wash sale:** a trade with no change in **beneficial ownership**, meaning the true owner stays the same.
- **Matched orders:** knowingly placing offsetting orders of about the same size, time and price to fake activity. The owners can differ.
- **Market rumors:** Section 9(a)(4) bars a seller from stating a material fact, to induce buying, that he has reason to believe is false. FINRA Rule 6140(e) sets a similar bar for members.
- **Pump and dump:** spreading hype to push up a stock, often a tiny one, then selling at the inflated price.
- **Marking the close or open:** trading at or near the end or start of a session to push that price. FINRA's Sanction Guidelines list both.
- **Excessive trading:** recommended trades that are too much when taken together. Turnover rate and cost-equity ratio are measures; no single test decides it.
- **Paid promotion (Rule 5230):** a firm may not pay to influence a publication unless the piece is clearly paid advertising, discloses the payment, or is a research report.
Example
Name each: (a) A trader sells between two accounts he alone owns. (b) Two friends agree to enter opposite 5,000-share orders at one price. (c) A trader buys above the offer at day's end to lift the closing price.
Solution
(a) Ownership never changes, so a wash sale.
(b) Ownership changes, so matched orders.
(c) Marking the close.
Trading ahead and other market abuses
- **Front running (Rule 5270):** trading a security or a related instrument, such as options, while knowing of an imminent **block** (generally 10,000 shares or more), until the news is public or stale.
- **Trading ahead of a customer (Rule 5320):** a firm holding a customer order may not trade the same side at a price that would fill it without immediately filling the customer at that price or better.
- **Trading ahead of research (Rule 5280):** changing the firm's own holdings on advance knowledge of a research report.
- **Backing away (Rule 5220):** refusing to trade at your own **firm quote**, a price you must honor.
- **Coordination (Rule 5240):** coordinating prices, or pressuring a rival to change a quote, as by refusing to trade.
- **Freeriding:** buying in a pay-in-full cash account and selling before paying. Regulation T then bars delayed payment for 90 calendar days.
Example
A firm holds a customer's order to buy 300 shares at $15, then buys 300 at $15 for itself. What must it do?
Solution
Fill the customer's 300 shares immediately at $15 or better. Otherwise it has traded ahead.
Insider trading
Insider trading is trading on material nonpublic information in breach of a duty of trust. Information is material when a reasonable investor would likely consider it important to a buy or sell decision. There is no percentage test.
- **Awareness (Rule 10b5-1):** being aware of the information when trading is enough, whatever the motive.
- **Who is involved:** SEC cases have reached officers, directors and employees; their **tippees** (friends, family and associates who trade on a tip); lawyers, bankers and printers working for the company; and government staff.
- **Plan defense:** a contract or written plan adopted before learning the information can protect later trades.
- **Misappropriation (Rule 10b5-2):** outsiders owe a duty if they agreed to keep a secret, have a history of sharing confidences, or got it from a spouse, parent, child or sibling.
- **Tippers:** passing on the information is a violation even without trading.
Example
Who owes a duty? (a) A brother tips his sister about a merger. (b) A stranger overhears news on a train. (c) Two friends with a long habit of keeping each other's work secrets.
Solution
(a) Yes, siblings are listed, though she may rebut it.
(b) No listed relationship and no agreement.
(c) Yes, a pattern of confidences creates a duty.
Insider trading penalties
- **Civil penalty (Section 21A):** up to three times the profit or avoided loss. Loss avoided uses the trading price a reasonable period after the news is public.
- **Firms:** a controlling person pays only if it knew of or recklessly ignored a likely violation, or recklessly failed to keep required policies.
- **Private suits (Section 20A):** investors trading at the same time can recover up to the profit or loss avoided, less any **disgorgement** (gains given up under a court order). A tipper is jointly and severally liable with the person tipped, so either can be made to pay the full amount.
- **Criminal (Section 32(a)):** up to $5 million and 20 years for a person, and up to $25 million for an entity.
- **FINRA:** by law it can fine, censure, suspend or expel a member firm, and suspend or bar a person from the industry. A 2018 marking-the-close decision barred a trader.
Example
An officer sells 4,000 shares at $50 knowing undisclosed bad news. After the news is public, the stock trades at $35. What is the maximum civil penalty, and the most he could owe investors trading at the same time?
Solution
Loss avoided = ($50 − $35) × 4,000 = $60,000.
Maximum civil penalty = 3 × $60,000 = $180,000.
Section 20A cap = $60,000, less anything disgorged.
Fraud, customer money and IPOs
- **Rule 10b-5:** bans schemes to defraud, false statements or misleading omissions of material fact, and deceptive conduct.
- **Registration claims (Rule 15c1-3):** a firm may not suggest SEC registration means the SEC approved it or its products.
- **Improper use (Rule 2150):** taking customer money is a violation, even if meant to be repaid.
- **Guarantees:** no one may guarantee a customer against loss.
- **Sharing in accounts:** needs prior written authorization from the firm and customer, and only in proportion to the money contributed. Accounts of parents, parents-in-law, spouses, children and supported relatives are exempt from the proportion limit.
- **Borrowing (Rule 3240):** generally banned unless firm procedures allow it and the lender fits a listed category. Personal-relationship loans need notice and written pre-approval.
- **IPOs (Rule 5130):** **restricted persons**, including broker-dealer staff and portfolio managers, may not buy a **new issue** (an equity IPO). Family members are restricted only with material support, a job at the selling firm or allocation control.
- **10% exemption:** an account may buy if restricted persons hold 10% or less.
Example
An RR put 25% of the money into a $40,000 joint account with an unrelated customer, with both written authorizations in place. The account gains $8,000. What is his largest share?
Solution
He may share only in proportion to his contribution: 25% × $8,000 = $2,000.
Seniors, unregistered persons and records
- **Rule 2165:** a firm may place a temporary hold on a disbursement or trade for a **specified adult** (65 or older, or 18 or older and impaired) if it reasonably believes exploitation is occurring.
- **Notice:** account parties and the trusted contact are told within two business days, unless suspected.
- **Paying unregistered persons (Rule 2040):** no trade-based pay to someone who would have to register as a broker-dealer, and the firm must be able to support its view that registration is not needed. Retiring **registered representatives (RRs)**, a firm's licensed salespeople, may keep commissions under a bona fide contract barring soliciting and servicing.
- **Taking orders (Rule 1230):** accepting orders is not clerical, so whoever accepts them must be registered. When a registered person is occasionally unavailable, an unregistered assistant may write down details, but the registered person confirms them with the customer before entry.
- **Soliciting (Rule 1220):** FINRA defines a representative as anyone associated with a member who is engaged in its securities business, and solicitation is on that list. So an unregistered assistant may not solicit customers.
- **False records:** changing an order time falsifies a required record under SEC Rule 17a-3.
- **Signatures of convenience:** signing a customer's name, even on an authorized trade, is unauthorized use of a signature under Rule 2010. An authorized trade or later customer approval can lower the sanction, not erase it.
- **Keeping records (Rule 4511):** firms must make and preserve required books and records, in a format meeting SEC Rule 17a-4. With no set period, FINRA's default is six years. Discarding a record early is a violation too.
- **Regulatory requests (Rule 8210):** firms and associated persons must provide information and testimony, including outside-activity records in their possession, custody or control. Failing to provide them, or withholding them, breaks the rule.
Example
How long can a Rule 2165 hold last with every extension?
Solution
15 initial + 10 after review + 30 after reporting to a state regulator, agency or court = 55 business days.
Key terms
- Wash sale
- A trade that leaves true ownership unchanged, used to fake market activity.
- Matched orders
- Offsetting orders of similar size, time and price placed knowingly to fake activity; owners may differ.
- Pump and dump
- Hyping a stock with misleading claims, then selling your shares at the inflated price.
- Marking the close
- Trading near the end of the session to set an artificial closing price.
- Front running
- Trading ahead of an imminent block transaction while its details are material and nonpublic.
- Backing away
- Failing to honor one's own firm quotation.
- Freeriding
- Selling in a cash account before paying; brings a 90-calendar-day freeze on delayed payment.
- Material
- Substantially likely to matter to a reasonable investor deciding whether to buy or sell.
- Misappropriation
- Trading on, or passing along, secret information taken by betraying a duty of trust or confidence.
- Tipper
- A person who unlawfully passes on inside information; liable even without trading.
- Section 21A penalty
- Civil fine of up to three times the profit or avoided loss.
- Section 20A cap
- Investors trading at the same time recover at most the profit or loss avoided, less disgorgement.
- Restricted person
- Someone barred from buying equity IPOs, such as broker-dealer staff and portfolio managers.
- De minimis exemption
- An IPO may go to an account if barred investors hold no more than 10% of it.
- Specified adult
- A customer 65 or older, or 18 or older with an impairment preventing self-protection.
- Beneficial ownership
- The true economic interest in a security, whatever name appears on the account.
- Tippee
- A person who receives inside information from someone else and trades on it.
- Expulsion
- FINRA's removal of a member firm from membership, one of the sanctions federal law lets it impose.
- Signature of convenience
- Signing for a customer to save time; unauthorized use of a signature even when the trade itself was authorized.
Common mistakes
- A wash sale keeps one owner. Matched orders can have different owners. Check whether ownership changes.
- Front running means a block is coming. Trading ahead of a customer means the firm already holds a customer order. Research front running involves a report.
- Insider trading needs only awareness at the time of the trade, with no profit minimum and no sole-motive test.
- Three times the gain is the Section 21A ceiling. The Section 20A cap is one times, reduced by disgorgement.
- Sharing profits follows the contribution unless the relative is on Rule 2150's list. A sibling you do not support is not listed, even though Rule 3240 counts siblings as family.
- Rule 5130 does not cover follow-on offerings by public companies, and an adult child with no support tie and no job at the selling firm is not automatically restricted.
Checked against: 15 U.S.C. 78i (Exchange Act Section 9, Manipulation of security prices); 15 U.S.C. 78t-1 (Exchange Act Section 20A, Liability to contemporaneous traders for insider trading); 15 U.S.C. 78u-1 (Exchange Act Section 21A, Civil penalties for insider trading); 15 U.S.C. 78ff (Exchange Act Section 32, Penalties); SEC Rule 10b-5 (Employment of manipulative and deceptive devices); SEC Rule 10b5-1 (Trading on the basis of material nonpublic information); SEC Rule 10b5-2 (Duties of trust or confidence in misappropriation cases); SEC Rule 12b-2 (Definitions, including material); SEC Rule 15c1-3 (Misrepresentation by brokers and dealers as to registration); SEC Rule 17a-3 (Records to Be Made by Certain Exchange Members, Brokers and Dealers); SEC Rule 15l-1 (Regulation Best Interest); 12 CFR 220.8 (Regulation T, cash account); SEC: Microcap Stock, A Guide for Investors; FINRA Office of Hearing Officers, Department of Market Regulation v. Meagher, No. 2011030509802 (2018); FINRA Rule 2111 (Suitability); FINRA Rule 5230 (Payments Involving Publications that Influence the Market Price of a Security); FINRA Rule 5270 (Front Running of Block Transactions); FINRA Rule 5320 (Prohibition Against Trading Ahead of Customer Orders); FINRA Rule 5280 (Trading Ahead of Research Reports); FINRA Rule 5220 (Offers at Stated Prices); FINRA Rule 5240 (Anti-Intimidation/Coordination); FINRA Rule 2150 (Improper Use of Customers' Securities or Funds; Prohibition Against Guarantees and Sharing in Accounts); FINRA Rule 5130 (Restrictions on the Purchase and Sale of Initial Equity Public Offerings); FINRA Rule 2165 (Financial Exploitation of Specified Adults); FINRA Rule 2020 (Use of Manipulative, Deceptive or Other Fraudulent Devices); FINRA Rule 6140 (Other Trading Practices); FINRA Rule 3240 (Borrowing From or Lending to Customers); FINRA Rule 2040 (Payments to Unregistered Persons); FINRA Rule 1230 (Associated Persons Exempt from Registration), Supplementary Material .01; FINRA Rule 8210 (Provision of Information and Testimony and Inspection and Copying of Books); SEC Investor.gov: Insider Trading; SEC Investor.gov: Market Manipulation; 15 U.S.C. 78o-3 (Exchange Act Section 15A, Registered securities associations), paragraph (b)(7); SEC Rule 17a-4 (Records to Be Preserved by Certain Exchange Members, Brokers and Dealers); FINRA Rule 4511 (General Requirements); SEC: Guide to Broker-Dealer Registration; FINRA Sanction Guidelines (March 2024); FINRA Rule 8310 (Sanctions for Violation of the Rules); FINRA Rule 1220 (Registration Categories)